Italian Citizenship

Italian Data Authority Fines Meta €805m for Facebook Photo Access

Italy's Garante fines Meta €805 million for unauthorized access to photos and metadata via the Facebook app on Android; Meta says it will appeal.

Italian Data Authority Fines Meta €805m for Facebook Photo Access
Foto: Isabelle K. – Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The Italian data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, imposed this week a fine of €805 millions on Meta for practices deemed to violate users’ privacy of the Facebook app on Android devices, according to ANSA. The company announced it will appeal the decision.

Sanction imposed by the Garante (Meta, Facebook, Garante, fine)

The Garante imposed a penalty of €805 millions on Meta for the way the Facebook app for Android allegedly accessed content stored on users' smartphones. According to ANSA, this amount represents about 0.47% of the group’s global revenue, a figure cited by the authority in its news release. The decision marks one of the largest recent fines in Europe against a social media platform for data protection concerns.

Reason for the fine: access to photos, videos and metadata (Facebook, privacy)

The investigation focused on the app feature called "Ottieni suggerimenti dalla galleria quando navighi su Facebook", launched in 2023, which aimed to suggest content from the phone’s gallery as ideas for posts. According to ANSA’s reporting on the Garante’s decision, the feature would have allowed access to photos, videos and metadata of users without explicit and informed consent for that handling.

The feature in question was presented as a publishing aid, but, according to the Garante, the manner of obtaining authorization and the presentation of purposes were insufficient to constitute valid consent.

Deficiencies found in the investigation (Garante, privacy, Facebook)

The inquiry opened in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Center, and, as reported by ANSA, identified several technical and transparency failures:

  • The app requested a single consent for gallery access across the entire application, without segmenting or limiting the purposes of processing.
  • The authorization was preceded by a generic notice — described as "abilitare altre funzioni" — which, according to the Garante, did not clarify the purposes of access to images and metadata.
  • The option to obtain gallery suggestions was pre-enabled, which could allow Facebook to read contents without an informed and specific consent from the data subject.

For the authority, these elements constituted data processing incompatible with the European data protection regulation’s requirements on legality, transparency, and specificity of consent.

Meta’s reaction (Meta, Facebook, appeal)

Meta announced it will appeal the decision and expressed disagreement with the factual assessment and the application of the law, ANSA reported. The company deemed the fine disproportionate and stressed that the feature was a publishing aid, which could be activated only with authorization on the device and adjusted in the user settings. In statements (cited by the press), Meta argued that it offered mechanisms for users to control the feature.

Relevance for Brazilians and descendants (privacy, Garante)

The Italian decision has informational impact for Facebook users in Brazil and for Brazilian descendants of Italians who follow Italian news, as it illustrates how European regulators can sanction global platforms when aspects of consent and transparency in processing personal data are deemed insufficient. For those researching digital life and rights on the internet — topics connected to Life in Italy and current events in Italy News covered by Raízes Italianas — the case reinforces attention to privacy settings in apps and to European authorities’ actions.

Users interested in citizenship and activities involving digital interactions may also find it relevant to monitor how regulatory decisions in Europe influence global platform practices and personal data protection, a topic with implications across areas, including for those tracking mobility between Brazil and Italy and issues related to Cidadania Italiana.

Conclusion The €805 million fine imposed by the Garante against Meta highlights European authorities’ priority in supervising automated processing of sensitive data in widely used apps and points to potential legal and administrative remedies to be pursued. The case remains a focal point for users and regulators regarding the limits of consent and transparency on digital platforms.

Source: ANSA

Read next